Silvergate Capital: If It Survives, It Could Thrive Beyond Measure

Trending 1 year ago
Bitcoin. CPU Concept

BlackJack3D/E+ via Getty Images

The important reversal successful cryptocurrencies has led to nan downfall of galore related stocks. One notable illustration is nan "crypto bank" Silvergate Capital (NYSE:SI), which has mislaid astir 95% of its worth since its 2021 peak. After specified an utmost loss, the banal has garnered immense short-selling activity, amounting to 73% of its outstanding shares. Undoubtedly, nan institution is astatine a captious turning constituent coming wherever it must beryllium its reliance done a difficult period. As implied by immense short positions facing nan stock, galore marketplace participants judge nan patient is yet doomed. However, its guardant "P/E" is now overmuch much reasonable astatine ~17X; if it tin beryllium its resiliency, it whitethorn beryllium owed for a short-squeeze and could beryllium a long-term turnaround investment.

Silvergate was 1 of my apical finance picks successful 2020. I took a bullish outlook connected the banal successful February 2020, believing that nan "business of crypto" would apt beryllium much profitable than cryptocurrencies. I remained bullish until February of 2021, erstwhile I warned nan banal was astir apt considerably overvalued aft rising 500% and was astatine consequence of dilution owed to its increasing request to raise capital. Since then, nan banal has plummeted, pinch equity dilution being 1 of galore challenges it has faced since. The astir important situation Silvergate has faced is nan demise of captious customers associated pinch nan important diminution successful nan cryptocurrency market. Additionally, nan banal has suffered monolithic devaluation owed to a beardown antagonistic displacement successful unit investor sentiment pursuing nan broader exertion roar and bust rhythm from 2020 to 2022.

2023 is nan "make aliases break" twelvemonth for Silvergate. SI has been little volatile since carving retired a bottommost successful December. The banal is now adjacent aliases beneath its "pre-bubble" price, almost for illustration nan past 3 years ne'er occurred. Overall, depending connected nan cryptocurrency marketplace and nan bank's clients, nan slope whitethorn not survive; if it does, it could present coagulated semipermanent returns.

A "Healing" Extinction Event?

As discussed astatine nan opening of nan twelvemonth regarding my bullish outlook connected Coinbase (COIN), nan cryptocurrency manufacture is going done a benignant of "mass extinction event." It is simply a acold much difficult clip to beryllium a cryptocurrency business. Investors are acold little consenting to supply abundant inexpensive capital, profits are considerably much challenging to generate, and astir are seeing gross fall. On nan surface, this business would look bearish for each cryptocurrency businesses, threatening nan industry's endurance entirely. However, successful my view, location are galore basal reasons to judge nan cryptocurrency manufacture will survive. If so, nan surviving cryptocurrency companies will apt travel retired of this business acold much efficiently pinch much robust business economics, less competitors, and greater entree to superior (due to a diminution successful competition).

Of course, Silvergate is simply a bank, not a broker, truthful its wellness is mostly limited connected nan manufacture arsenic a whole. After suffering ample deposit declines, nan institution had to pursue monolithic layoffs and investment sales. Undoubtedly, this business is troubling successful nan short run. Still, successful nan agelong run, it whitethorn make nan institution much resilient pinch a stronger operational attraction connected its champion businesses, specified arsenic its exchange network. The institution has besides attracted galore ample organization investors recently, for illustration State Street, BlackRock, and Citadel Securities.

The banal is now a important target for institutional investors, pinch individual stakeholders having acold little vulnerability to nan firm. In my view, that alteration indicates that galore financial institutions judge successful nan patient (particularly astatine its existent valuation), perchance lowering its competitory risks from larger banks (or expanding its strategical acquisition potential). Further, pinch individual stakeholders only making up ~5% of its ownership, nan stock's valuation is apt compressed owed to a monolithic diminution successful (often irrational) unit investor exuberance.

Of course, organization investors often do not make nan champion bets and whitethorn underweight nan risks facing Silvergate. In my view, nan cryptocurrency manufacture will past (due to increasing world fiat rate volatility) and perchance scope a cyclical bottommost (as seen successful BTC's support). Silvergate has galore supporters and opponents (being 1 of nan astir short-sold stocks today), expanding nan anticipation of a important volatility summation successful either direction. Based connected astir each financial metrics, nan slope is successful a unspeakable information coming owed to a diminution successful deposits. However, fundamentally, if nan institution provides worth to nan cryptocurrency industry, it has survival potential.

Strong Asset Liquidity Offsets Deposit Risk

Silvergate arguably did not adequately hole itself for nan immense cryptocurrency business cycles. While it operates arsenic a bank, its depositors are each situated successful an highly volatile business, giving nan slope acold much consequence vulnerability than accepted banks (which activity to diversify their exposures). That said, Silvergate does not run a ample lending book and has acold much blimpish investments than astir commercialized banks. Still, nan slope has suffered tremendous losses owed to nan crisp diminution successful deposits and an alarming summation successful its leverage level. See below:

ChartData by YCharts

The institution ended Q4 pinch a Tier 1 superior ratio of only 5.36% and a staggering $33 EPS loss. Silvergate estimated its adjusted book worth per stock astatine $12.93, beneath its GAAP level and somewhat beneath its existent price. Its superior level was very debased astatine nan extremity of Q4, creating liquidity risks if its depositors continued to flee. That said, astir 90% of nan company's assets are either rate (40%), Treasury, aliases MBS enslaved securities (50%). Those assets are acold much liquid than loans, person little in installments risk, and little returns. Thus, while its extremity Q4 superior ratio is alarming, it is little truthful successful ray of its highly blimpish plus equilibrium sheet.

As mentioned successful its investor presentation, its full deposits fluctuated from $11.9B to $3.5B during Q4, creating an utmost range. Depositor volatility was elevated owed to nan FTX ungraded and "contagion effect" fears. Obviously, a slope cannot safely run pinch specified immense volatility successful deposits; however, nan truth that Silvergate survived that play is simply a testament to its beardown plus liquidity.

The slope still posted a non-GAAP affirmative EPS successful Q4 contempt volatility. Its nett liking margins declined from 2.2% to 1.5% owed to accrued deposit liking costs. With nan output curve immensely inverted, this will apt beryllium a greater rumor successful Q1 arsenic depositor costs could proceed to emergence disproportionately successful information yields. Additionally, nan company's SEN web saw activity emergence from Q3 to Q4 contempt immense depositor withdrawals, indicating that business whitethorn beryllium nan backbone of early stability. Finally, while nan company's EPS is apt acold weaker successful 2023, analysts still expect $0.83 successful EPS this year. At that EPS, nan patient has a "P/E" of ~16-17X today, which is arguably debased considering its net should emergence considerably complete nan coming years. SI is besides very adjacent to its book value, suggesting a coagulated value level for nan banal arsenic agelong arsenic broader crypto marketplace volatility remains low.

The Bottom Line

Silvergate faces nan "thrive aliases demise" precipice for illustration galore cryptocurrency businesses today. It faces galore challenges jeopardizing its survival, namely nan nonaccomplishment of depositors owed to nan ongoing "crypto depression." However, I do not judge Silvergate is astatine consequence of a accelerated "bank run" arsenic galore accepted banks can be since its assets are highly liquid and it has fewer accepted loans. In different words, arsenic agelong arsenic nan US Treasury continues paying its obligations, nan slope tin easy springiness rate to depositors wishing to withdraw.

Assuming nan cryptocurrency manufacture survives nan depression, I judge Silvergate is mostly apt to arsenic well. The institution has nary existent adjacent aliases nonstop competitors that are truthful heavy invested successful nan cryptocurrency business. Its deficiency of diversification whitethorn beryllium a consequence factor, but it besides creates a sizeable moat since I judge cryptocurrency businesses will ever for illustration banks that are well-acquainted pinch nan industry.

In nan agelong run, Silvergate's moat whitethorn turn if it continues to create financial technologies, specified arsenic nan SEN network, that differentiate it further from accepted banks. Additionally, nan company's ample layoff and closure of galore non-core businesses is, successful my opinion, comparatively patient and whitethorn amended nan company's semipermanent worth and efficiency. Assuming that constraints spur innovation, I judge Silvergate will get from nan "crypto depression" a leaner and much resilient endeavor pinch a stronger semipermanent focus.

That said, Silvergate's endurance is not guaranteed. While its highly liquid plus vulnerability dramatically lowers nan consequence associated pinch nan nonaccomplishment of depositors, 2023 will apt beryllium challenging and, if capable depositors flee, could not survive. However, I judge that arsenic agelong arsenic nary caller ample cryptocurrency scandals unfold and Bitcoin and its peers support immoderate value stability, nan worst is now down Silvergate. As seen successful nan monolithic short-selling pursuing nan stock, location is simply a awesome woody of "fear" astir nan stock, creating a higher imaginable for important undervaluation.

Silvergate is comparatively inexpensive today, peculiarly compared to its 2021-2022 yearly EPS scope of $1.50-$3.85. If nan company's EPS returns to specified levels, its guardant "P/E" coming would only beryllium 3.6X to 9.4X. Of course, successful 2021, galore investors powerfully believed Silvergate's EPS would emergence overmuch higher. If cryptocurrency ever straight contends pinch fiat currency, Silvergate's worth would apt beryllium tremendously supra its existent level. Of course, that is simply a very speculative bet, peculiarly considering nan lackluster sentiment surrounding cryptocurrency.

I americium somewhat bullish connected SI coming for a fewer cardinal reasons. Firstly, it is simply a diversified stake from astir stocks pinch little nonstop economical vulnerability (and could use from a recession if crypto request rises). Secondly, nan company's valuation is objectively debased compared to its EPS imaginable and historically debased compared to its book value. Thirdly, while SI has somewhat elevated bankruptcy risk, I judge its basal upside is important if it manages to past and becomes a much businesslike firm. At this point, I deliberation sizeable be aware is warranted arsenic SI could autumn further owed to short-selling activity aliases different diminution successful cryptocurrencies. That said, SI whitethorn besides beryllium owed for a short compression considering nan immense short positioning against nan firm.

This article was written by

Harrison Schwartz floor plan picture

Harrison is simply a financial expert who has been penning connected Seeking Alpha since 2018 and has intimately followed nan marketplace for complete a decade. He has master acquisition successful nan backstage equity, existent estate, and economical investigation industry. Harrison besides has an world inheritance successful financial econometrics, economical forecasting, and world monetary economics.

Disclosure: I/we person nary stock, action aliases akin derivative position successful immoderate of nan companies mentioned, but whitethorn initiate a beneficial Long position done a acquisition of nan stock, aliases nan acquisition of telephone options aliases akin derivatives successful SI complete nan adjacent 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my ain opinions. I americium not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I person nary business narration pinch immoderate institution whose banal is mentioned successful this article.

Editor: Naga

Read other contents from at
More Source