Kohl's: Mediocre Times Ahead, But Hidden Assets Are Key

Trending 1 year ago

Kohl"s Department Stores Receives Unsolicited Bid From Hedge Fund Starboard Value LP

Justin Sullivan

Who is Kohl's

Kohl's Corporation (NYSE:KSS) is simply a unit institution operating successful nan United States. The institution offers a wide scope of products including apparel, footwear, accessories, beauty products, and family items done its brick-and-mortar stores and online platform.

These products are chiefly sold nether well-known marque names specified arsenic Apt. 9, Croft & Barrow, and Vera Wang, among others.

Kohl's has had a difficult decade arsenic online retailers person aggressively gained marketplace stock done charismatic pricing and taking advantage of changes successful user behaviors.

This is reflected successful nan company's stock price, which has gradually declined complete nan past decade.

ChartData by YCharts

Investment thesis

Brick-and-mortar is not needfully dead, however. The manufacture is showing signs of life and manufacture trends are erstwhile again shifting. Our position is that unit is showing signs of attractiveness, pinch upside imaginable for fundamentally strong businesses. We intend to analyse Kohl's pinch nan position to assessing if nan business has nan characteristics basal to outperform successful nan coming years aliases if different options for worth could make alpha. This will impact considerations of its financial profile, and really nan business is being impacted by economical conditions, alongside nan aforementioned manufacture trends we person identified.

E-commerce and brick-and-mortar

E-commerce retailers person recovered occurrence by offering affordable prices, plentifulness of options, and convenient transportation options. These online businesses person little overhead costs owed to nan deficiency of storefronts, pinch resources alternatively diverted to trading efforts. This has made it incredibly difficult for storefront retailers to compete.

Kohl's has faced challenges successful adapting to nan inclination of accrued online shopping, which contributed to nan business struggling during COVID-19. The business knowledgeable a 20.1% diminution successful income during FY21, pinch a bounce backmost of only 21.8%. The business has yet to return to its pre-COVID level (Source: CapIQ). As of FY21, only 32% of income were done online channels, which is up 11% from 2019. Given that nan play in-between was wholly lockdown owed to COVID, our anticipation would beryllium for nan business to execute person to 40%.

We spot important value connected this ratio because e-commerce continues to turn astatine an impressive rate compared to accepted brick-and-mortar establishments. According to Statista, this inclination is expected to persist and support its singular maturation trajectory.

Retail e-commerce maturation (Statista)

Further, it is important to place that nan younger procreation is those driving e-commerce growth. They are nan early and truthful nan retailers they subordinate pinch are acold much apt to win semipermanent arsenic agelong arsenic they tin support their relevancy. This is 1 of nan large reasons why retailers that autumn retired of favour pinch nan trend-driving procreation usually struggle to regain a footing successful nan market.

Despite nan maturation of e-commerce, brick-and-mortar unit continues to connection benefits. The return to beingness stores has been impressive, pinch 94% of customers returning pursuing lockdowns. Additionally, galore consumers take to shop some online and in-store, pinch 29% opting for online purchases pinch in-store pick-up. This demonstrates that brick-and-mortar is not becoming obsolete and tin really complement online shopping. This presents a affirmative outlook for Kohl's, arsenic its extended brick-and-mortar beingness allows for greater accessibility and convenience. Currently, Kohl's is classed arsenic nan 27th largest retailer successful nan US, including some online and beingness retailers, pinch complete 1,000 stores nationwide.

Sephora x Kohl's

Kohl's has consistently accrued nan beingness of Sephora unit services wrong its stores. Sephora, a French individual attraction and beauty merchandise institution owned by LVMHF, has seen awesome maturation arsenic consumers go much fashion-conscious. This maturation has propelled LVMH to record-breaking results successful 2022, showing nan value of this marque to LVMH. By having Sephora services wrong its stores, Kohl's increases its chances of trading its ain merchandise to customers searching for Sephora products. Further, it brings young (and influential) group into their stores. This is simply a cleanable cross-selling opportunity. Data suggests that this move has been highly accretive for Kohl's, pinch shop publication being importantly higher astatine locations pinch a Sephora presence. Furthermore, guidance is readying to unfastened an awesome 600+ Sephora locations this year, compared to 200 past year, according to nan Q4-22 property release.

Brick-and-mortar is intelligibly showing opportunities for maturation done invention and strategical decision-making. Consumers person shown that they will travel to stores if fixed a compelling logic to, which is why this move from Kohl's is genius.

The nonaccomplishment of nan CEO

Kohl's has appointed Tom Kingsbury arsenic imperishable CEO pursuing nan departure of Michelle Gass, who near to return complete astatine Levi Strauss. This comes arsenic activistic investor Macellum Advisors has been pressuring nan committee for reform, pinch Tom being a nominee of theirs.

With nan assignment taking spot successful nan past fewer weeks, we person yet to spot nan strategical guidance Tom has for nan business and further specifications astir really nan committee convinced Macellum to motion a Cooperation agreement.

This was an unplanned departure, suggesting Michelle either had an rumor pinch nan existent business astatine Kohl's aliases saw a amended opportunity pinch Levi. We are not successful nan business of speculating and truthful will purely authorities that this is simply a problem for Kohl's.

Activist investors tin person some affirmative and antagonistic impacts, but fixed nan prolonged play of underperformance, we judge that caller perspectives tin beryllium beneficial. Kohl's has a beardown instauration pinch its business pinch Sephora and tin leverage this to grow its scope toward its target audience.

Kohl's assets

Historically, galore ample businesses pinch important beingness assets preferred to ain their properties outright. However, successful caller decades, location has been a displacement towards leasing and replacement financing methods arsenic liking rates person trended down, freeing up superior for growth. Kohl's has a important magnitude of PPE worthy complete $8 billion, overmuch of which are premier assets successful nan United States. This provides investors pinch nan opportunity to ain these valuable assets, which a imaginable acquirer of Kohl's whitethorn worth astatine a premium. For example, a sale-and-leaseback script could free up billions of dollars. Kohl's has an equity worth of $4 cardinal and a marketplace capitalization of c.$3.6 billion, offering investors imaginable returns done liquidation alone.

A akin business occurred successful nan UK, wherever Morrisons supermarket caused a bidding warfare betwixt galore of nan starring PE firms, each of whom attributed important worth to nan company's extended portfolio of beingness assets. CD&R won, paying £7BN (compared to a £4.2BN marketplace headdress earlier nan first offer, £4.2BN equity value, and £8.2BN nett PPE). They person already engaged successful asset selling and S&LB transactions. Using this arsenic a comp, Kohl's has important upside and is positioned good arsenic a buy-out target.

Management did move down a $53 takeover bid from Franchise Group successful mid-2022, suggesting they judge location to beryllium greater worth successful nan business. With liking rates remaining elevated, it could beryllium difficult to finance specified a woody presently but our position is that this is simply a awesome opportunity for personification erstwhile rates normalize.

Kohl's financials


P&L (CapIQ)

Kohl's has seen a prolonged alteration successful income complete time, owed successful portion to nan trouble successful competing pinch different retailers. Upon examining nan 3rd 4th of 2022 results, some comparable and nett income person dropped. Although nan institution faces aggravated competition, nan weakened economical conditions person besides played a role. With liking rates and ostentation being importantly higher than nan mean of nan past decade, consumers are facing financial pressures, causing request to alteration arsenic they activity to trim backmost connected spending. As a result, unit income person begun to drop.

ChartData by YCharts

Additionally, GPM has seen a flimsy alteration complete nan past 12 months, but much importantly successful Q3-22, owed to higher freight and nan inability to raise prices. heightened costs are a consequence of nan existent inflationary pressures, pinch persistent ostentation caused by supply-side problems. Our outlook is that ostentation will stay persistent for nan mostly of 2023, pinch a diminution only towards nan extremity of nan year. We are unsure really overmuch further rates will request to emergence to execute this, but realistically 50bps much looks due currently. As a result, margins will astir apt acquisition a further diminution successful nan coming quarters. We would beryllium very concerned if GPM falls beneath 38 successful immoderate 1 quarter. The institution cannot raise unit prices to counteract this, which is unsurprising fixed really competitory unit is. This has translated to a diminution successful bottom-line margins, arsenic nan business has been incapable to execute nan S&A efficiencies capable to offset nan increases successful costs.


Balance expanse (CapIQ)

Kohl's indebtedness equilibrium has gradually accrued successful caller years, pinch a ample uptick successful nan LTM period. This has contributed to a diminution successful its in installments ratios, pinch only a 3.4x sum of liking and a nett indebtedness / EBITDA ratio of 3.8x. Our targets for these ratios would beryllium 8x and 3x, respectively, which suggests nan business has drifted acold from a comfortable financial position. Management intends to statesman a play of deleveraging, pinch each buybacks paused until nan nett indebtedness ratio reaches 2.5x. This has resulted successful a BB+ standing from S&P, which indicates a important grade of consequence and a precocious coupon complaint for overmuch of its debt. With FCF output turning antagonistic successful nan LTM period, we are somewhat concerned arsenic to really this will beryllium funded successful nan contiguous term.


Credit standing (Q3-22 property release)

Interestingly, nan inventory turnover complaint has importantly decreased, contributing to nan antagonistic free rate travel that has been observed. This indicates that nan stores are having trouble trading inventory, perchance owed to a diminution successful demand. Only 5% of nan 34% summation from nan erstwhile twelvemonth is related to Sephora, which confirms this arsenic a build-up of halfway stock. This will apt lead to little margins successful nan coming twelvemonth arsenic discounts are offered to waste nan items. We would beryllium remiss not to mention that Management believes that OPM will return to 8%, which implies a separator description of c.2.5% from LTM levels.

Peer group analysis


Comp group financials (CapIQ)

Kohl's is presently underperforming a cohort of akin businesses, pinch a somewhat little EBITDA separator and very mediocre FCF yield. This is each while utilizing importantly much leverage to make returns. This said, nan company's normalized level of EBITDA separator is person to 12%, and its FCF output is person to 5%, suggesting nan institution does person nan expertise to execute astatine this level. If Management's execution is successful statement pinch their forecast, Kohl's tin return to this level this year. Nonetheless, our position is that they are a weaker personnel of nan unit community.

Kohl's valuation


comp group valuations (CapIQ)

Kohl's is trading astatine a discount to its counterparts while paying a importantly larger dividend. This reflects nan clear inferiority of nan business, pinch investors pricing weaker profitability and declining growth.

Kohl's has historically traded astatine a 6x NTM EBITDA multiple, suggesting nan business is somewhat overvalued. This said we person conducted a DCF valuation of nan business which implies an upside of 12%. This is based connected nan presumption that FCF will stay wrong $550-800M, beneath its humanities average. Further, we presume an exit aggregate of 6x and perpetual maturation of 2%.

Final thoughts:

Kohl's has shown hints of opportunity going forward, pinch e-commerce income improving, B-A-M remaining robust, and nan description of its Sephora partnership. Currently, however, this has not translated into improving financials. We could spot a script erstwhile unit request continues to diminution but improved economics done nan Sephora description acts arsenic a buffer.

Further, nan business tin beryllium comparable to its peers, yet presently is performing poorly and is priced arsenic such. Our outlook is that financials will proceed to worsen and truthful a normalization to its humanities financial floor plan could return 12-24 months.

So, why did we springiness a "buy" standing to this stock? The reply is not based connected our discounted rate travel valuation. It's because nan worth of its assets is excessively charismatic to place astatine its existent stock price. We are assured that imaginable acquires are presently evaluating Kohl's, pinch nan only important hindrance being nan costs of borrowing, which is apt to enactment elevated for a fewer much quarters. However, we don't attraction connected timing nan market, truthful spot worth successful starting a mini position now.

Editor's Note: This article discusses 1 aliases much securities that do not waste and acquisition connected a awesome U.S. exchange. Please beryllium alert of nan risks associated pinch these stocks.

This article was written by

Welbeck Ash Research floor plan picture

The attraction of our investigation is to supply insightful and caller ideas, done heavy bottom-up business analysis. We look to show a communicative and place nan hallmarks of sustainable quality. Our position is nonsubjective and not sway by nan emotion of marketplace sentiment and short-term desires.

Disclosure: I/we person nary stock, action aliases akin derivative position successful immoderate of nan companies mentioned, and nary plans to initiate immoderate specified positions wrong nan adjacent 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my ain opinions. I americium not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I person nary business narration pinch immoderate institution whose banal is mentioned successful this article.

Editor: Naga

Read other contents from at
More Source