Jackson Financial Isn't Quite As Cheap As It Seems

megaflopp

Jackson Financial (NYSE:JXN) has been showing up connected investors' radars recently. The annuity security institution was agelong a portion of nan British financial patient Prudential (PUK). However, Prudential spun nan patient disconnected successful 2021 in an effort to refocus its operations much astir maturation opportunities successful emerging markets.

This created a classical orphaned information situation. Existing Prudential shareholders sewage conscionable 1 stock of Jackson for each 40 shares they held of nan genitor company. As a result, astir shareholders ended up pinch an inconsequential holding successful Jackson and apt disposed of it. In addition, having Prudential listed successful a different continent arsenic Jackson led to a batch of shareholders that sewage shares that they didn't want to clasp onto. Prudential quickly sold down its remaining shares successful Jackson pursuing nan spin-off, arsenic well.

Jackson shares initially traded poorly, arsenic is communal pinch this benignant of spin-off. However, shares person now picked up momentum and moved to caller highs recently:

Data by YCharts

Adding to these favorable spin-off dynamics, nan banal is gaining momentum pinch quantitative screeners. For example, astatine nan clip of this writing, Jackson Financial is nan top-ranked banal successful nan financial assemblage according to Seeking Alpha's quant system. Moreover, it is nan #8 banal retired of nan thousands tracked by nan quant overall:

JXN study (Seeking Alpha Quant Ratings)

Jackson Financial has scored an A+ standing successful 4 retired of 5 categories, and nan A- successful net revisions isn't bad either.

Looking astatine nan trailing net numbers, it's not difficult to spot nan excitement. Jackson's shares are trading astatine a rock-bottom P/E ratio while trading astatine a awesome discount to book value. Meanwhile, net person been growing, and shares are hitting caller 52-week highs. There are a batch of affirmative factors here. However, let's dive successful a small deeper.

Big Beneficiary From Higher Interest Rates

While Jackson Financial is reporting tremendous earnings, it's important to statement that nan institution sells annuity security policies. These person intricate accounting, acknowledgment to nan assortment of moving parts that create complexity erstwhile translated done GAAP standards.

An insurer gets premiums upfront from policyholders, and past owes a larger sum astatine a overmuch later day successful nan future. Jackson's results will dangle successful ample portion connected nan returns it tin get from its investments successful some equity and fixed income products successful nan interim.

Not surprisingly, insurers thin to for illustration higher liking rates. They tin get higher returns connected their fixed income holdings successful a precocious complaint environment. Furthermore, nan early worth of money declines successful a higher rate/higher ostentation environment, causing nan early liabilities of nan insurer to diminution successful existent terms.

In its 10-K, Jackson Financial notes that:

"Interest complaint consequence vulnerability for adaptable annuities increases erstwhile nan coming worth of expected early use payments increases.

The coming worth of expected early use payments increases owed to factors including equity marketplace underperformance, debased liking rates, adverse policyholder behaviour and accrued longevity.

As a result, little liking rates summation nan coming worth of our adaptable annuity vulnerability and mostly lead to accrued hedging needs and associated costs."

This whitethorn sound confusing, but, successful effect, erstwhile liking rates are low, Jackson Financial has higher effective liabilities. Furthermore, it has to return retired much liking complaint hedges erstwhile rates are debased to guarantee it tin meet policyholder claims, which is simply a resistance connected profitability.

Now, let's flip this around. In 2022, liking rates enjoyed a historical surge. Since debased rates are bad for Jackson Financial, we tin use nan inverse. The institution enjoyed a tremendous tailwind past twelvemonth arsenic rates soared, frankincense improving its early liability position and moving its hedging book sharply successful its favor.

Later on, successful its 10-K, Jackson notes that little liking rates would adversely impact its financial results and that:

"The measurement we hedge optional guaranteed benefits of our annuities could origin important variability successful our U.S. GAAP accounting results".

And indeed, that is very overmuch nan case. The mostly of Jackson's net volatility successful a fixed twelvemonth appears to beryllium caused by nan firm's hedging programme alternatively than nan underlying security business.

To that point, present are Jackson's GAAP net per stock complete nan past 4 years:

• 2022 (first 9 months): $71.73
• 2021: $33.86
• 2020: -$24.14
• 2019: -$13.16

Obviously, if nan institution could support delivering results for illustration 2021 aliases 2022, it would beryllium an exceptionally inexpensive company. On nan different hand, nan institution mislaid a mixed $37 per stock successful 2019 and 2020. When considering nan very debased P/E Jackson trades astatine presently, retrieve that these net tin plaything dramatically to nan antagonistic erstwhile rates move unfavorable.

This is nan rumor pinch utilizing net per stock to judge security companies pinch immense hedge books and liking complaint sensitivity. Short-term results are going to beryllium a highly magnified reflection of immoderate guidance liking rates are swinging astatine nan moment. As agelong arsenic rates are trending favorably, Jackson should station precocious reported GAAP earnings. On nan different hand, erstwhile liking rates move backmost down, Jackson will apt return to reporting outright losses, possibly of a sizeable amount.

I'd besides statement that Jackson's book worth has fallen since January 2022, successful ample portion because higher liking rates origin nan mark-to-market worth of existing fixed income securities to fall:

Data by YCharts

Is it bad that nan firm's book worth has dropped significantly? Not really. This is communal pinch security firms and banks that clasp tons of bonds connected their equilibrium sheets successful a rising liking complaint environment. That said, investors should statement that accounting is analyzable erstwhile a institution tin study $71/share successful net and yet person its book worth spell down.

The Brighthouse Example

Jackson Financial isn't nan only benignant of institution we've seen successful this lane. Years ago, elephantine insurer MetLife (MET) spun disconnected its annuity business Brighthouse Financial (BHF).

Brighthouse attracted a ample worth investor contingent, including David Einhorn, acknowledgment to looking really inexpensive and having nan favorable spinoff dynamics. And yet, Brighthouse has been a bumpy ride.

At 1 point, nan institution reported much than $40/share successful net successful 2020. On nan different hand, it would spell connected to study a $70/share nonaccomplishment not excessively agelong thereafter. Trailing twelve-month net topped $20/share past twelvemonth earlier precocious moving backmost into nan loss-making territory:

Data by YCharts

How has Brighthouse, nan stock, performed amid specified a roller coaster of earnings? It's been volatile:

Data by YCharts

Shares person recovered astir of their losses but still waste and acquisition beneath wherever MetLife primitively spun them disconnected at. In immoderate case, having (at times) a very debased P/E ratio didn't guarantee home-run finance returns.

Jackson's Bottom Line

I'm connected nan obstruction betwixt a clasp and a bargain outlook for Jackson's stock. Interest rates are rising erstwhile again, meaning that nan institution should footwear disconnected 2023 pinch much favorable earnings. There are besides nan affirmative spin-off dynamics; it appears that shares are uncovering a much enthusiastic ownership base, and existent momentum is building down nan company's story.

Jackson is returning tons of superior to shareholders arsenic well. Shares output 4.5% and location is simply a sizeable buyback programme arsenic well.

At nan extremity of nan day, I conscionable can't get past nan weird net dynamic, however.

I bought into nan Brighthouse communicative soon aft nan MetLife spin-off and thought I'd recovered a very inexpensive banal that nan marketplace was missing. Instead, it turned out, I had grounded to understand nan complexity of nan business model. I fearfulness that erstwhile Jackson's reported net caput backmost into antagonistic territory erstwhile liking rates reverse themselves, we'll spot a important diminution successful nan stock value arsenic well.