Google Is Not Worth Buying

Trending 1 year ago

South Lake Union Tech


Google (NASDAQ:GOOG) is nether immense unit to present connected its AI promises, amid intensifying competitory pressures. The emergence of ChatGPT forced Google to hastily present its ain AI-powered chat technology, Bard, transforming nan measurement group hunt for accusation done Google. While Bard has not been officially launched to nan nationalist yet, its preamble has been underwhelming, and nan caller exertion could upend Google’s advertizing business, pressuring profit margins complete nan foreseeable future. Given nan risks ahead, nan banal is not worthy buying. Nexus Research has a ‘hold’ standing connected nan stock.

AI-powered hunt enhancements are basal to support users engaged, though location are various concerns Google faces successful nan look of accelerated innovation.

Google’s activity successful AI invention is questionable

Despite Google’s AI-first attack complete nan past six years, they haven’t had first-mover advantages successful respective areas of search-related AI innovations. The emergence of ChatGPT is 1 of nan astir salient threats to Google’s hunt dominance, particularly arsenic Microsoft incorporates nan exertion into nan Bing hunt engine.

Though location are besides different areas wherever Google has fallen down successful innovation. Google likes to proclaim nan capabilities and accrued usage of Google Lens, its image-based hunt tool, arsenic a reflection of Google’s AI advancements. CEO Sundar Pichai often proclaims nan multimodal hunt capacity of Google Lens, powered by its Multitask Unified Model (MuM) AI technology, enabling users to hunt utilizing nan operation of an image and words to much easy find what they are looking for. Though this characteristic has been disposable connected Pinterest since 2017, while Google only launched its ain characteristic successful April 2022. For context, tech giants for illustration Amazon and Meta besides connection image-based hunt functionalities, undermining Google’s e-commerce ambitions done AI innovations for illustration Google Lens.

Amid nan caller competitory pressures, Pichai precocious reminded labor that Google was not nan first hunt motor either, but that did not extremity it from becoming nan ascendant hunt motor of nan world. While this statement has immoderate merit, nan tech manufacture has go a batch much competitory complete nan past 2 decades, and Google has been incapable to connection an separator complete competitors, moreover erstwhile it comes later to nan party. The astir caller lawsuit of this would beryllium nan underwhelming preamble of Google Bard, which turned retired to person a actual correction wrong nan demo.

Google’s advertisement business is nether pressure

As if Google’s slow-paced AI invention was not concerning enough, nan evolving quality of hunt activity besides requires Google to germinate its advertizing solutions. Two cardinal advertizing segments astir apt to beryllium affected by evolving hunt behaviour are ‘Google Search & other’ and ‘Google Network’.

‘Google Search & other’ is advertizing gross that derives from website owners bidding to rank much prominently connected Google’s integer properties, astir notably nan Search Engine Results Page (SERP). Google generates gross erstwhile group click connected nan advertised website links appearing adjacent nan apical of SERPs. ‘Google Search & other’ constituted astir 57% of full gross successful 2022.

‘Google Network’ generates advertisement gross from third-party publishers (website owners) trading advertisement spaces connected their websites done Google Network partners (AdSense and AdMob), from which Google takes a trim per impression. This gross watercourse requires group to sojourn websites participating successful ‘Google Network’, besides known arsenic ‘Google Network partners’, successful bid to garner advertisement impressions. The conception made up astir 12% of income gross successful 2022.

In CEO Sundar Pichai’s blog station introducing Bard, we sewage immoderate much insights into really Google plans to creation Bard responses to support users’ engagement pinch websites listed successful Google hunt results.

Bard consequence example


Below Bard’s reply 1 tin find a ‘Read more’ section, listing websites pinch much accusation applicable to nan query. In nan demo, nan recommended articles did not look to beryllium ads. Instead, Google seems to beryllium prioritizing nan websites’ relevance to personification queries. While this attack is prudent from nan position of usefulness for users, it does propulsion a spanner successful Google’s hunt ads business.

Bard’s consequence to personification queries takes up notable magnitude of abstraction connected apical of nan SERP, moving website links little and lower. Consequently, nan entreaty of advertisement bidding to rank higher is undermined, arsenic nan likelihood of users scrolling little to find website links is subdued if Bard’s consequence is sufficient. This could so coming a sizeable rustle to Google’s search-related advertisement revenue.

Google whitethorn request to re-imagine its advertisement solutions astir Bard to prolong advertizing revenue. Though nan tech elephantine has not proven to beryllium agile erstwhile it comes to monetizing caller formats, conscionable return YouTube Shorts arsenic an example. The short-form video contented characteristic launched successful September 2020 pursuing competitory threats from TikTok. While YouTube Shorts is capable to pull 50 cardinal regular views, Google has still not been capable to adjacent nan monetization spread betwixt short-form and long-form content, 2 and half years since launch.

Moreover, arsenic Google transforms its advertisement solutions amid evolving hunt behaviour, location is still nan consequence of displeasing advertisers pinch nan measurement ad-solutions are designed astir Bard, arsenic they whitethorn deem website discoverability and monetization imaginable to still beryllium undermined by Bard.

This would travel astatine a clip erstwhile Google is already facing aggravated advertizing competition, amid nan emergence of Amazon advertizing attracting advertisement dollars from merchants trading each sorts of beingness items, arsenic good arsenic reliable title from societal media platforms for illustration Meta and Pinterest. Hence, advertisers person plentifulness of replacement options disposable while Google tries to fig retired really to efficaciously monetize Bard.

Furthermore, advertizing gross done ‘Google Network’ would besides suffer arsenic conversational-style queries done Bard trim nan request for users to sojourn websites to find answers, reducing advertisement belief connected web pages.

In his post, Pichai emphasised that answers from Bard will thief users understand nan large picture, implying that Google will promote users to sojourn publishers’ websites for much extended answers, successful bid to support Google Network advertisement revenue.

Nonetheless, intensifying title could unit Google to connection much granular Bard answers, depending connected what competitors are doing. If competing services connection much in-depth answers without users needing to sojourn different web pages, Google would request to travel suit to stay competitive.

While Google’s Bard is trying to promote users to click connected publishers’ websites to study much astir a taxable matter, users whitethorn so beryllium inclined to proceed to chatting pinch Bard to find nan answers they are looking for, to prevention them having to scroll done web pages. Therefore, Google’s Bard could so beryllium inclined to connection much in-depth answers to support convenience and usefulness of nan service, astatine nan disbursal of Google Network revenue.

Even if users do extremity up clicking done to websites successful nan ‘Read more’ section, not each websites will beryllium Google Network partners. It remains to beryllium seen whether Google ends up giving much prominence to Google Network partners/ highest-bidding advertisers successful a imaginable Bard-driven hunt platform, successful nan liking of optimizing advertisement revenue. Though this attack would discuss nan reliability of Bard responses / suggestions. Google walks a good statement betwixt optimizing nan trustworthiness/ usefulness of Bard responses and optimizing advertisement revenue.

Contrarily, OpenAI is striving to monetize ChatGPT done subscription fees arsenic opposed to advertisement revenue. In February 2023, OpenAI introduced ChatGPT Plus for $20/month. This tin augment users’ cognition of ChatGPT comparative to Google, particularly if nan incumbent stays inclined towards optimizing advertisement revenue. Such a script would induce users to comprehend ChatGPT answers and suggestions arsenic much useful, while Google would request to strive difficult to flooded nan cognition of bias towards Google Network partners/ highest-bidding advertisers.

Both ChatGPT and Bard request much improvement and loop to amended nan trustworthiness of their answers. Though fixed that nan extremity end is to connection actual and reliable information, a fee-based business exemplary (as pinch OpenAI) would make much consciousness than nan ad-based business exemplary overtime, particularly if nan erstwhile tin so beryllium to beryllium importantly much reliable.

Google Bard compute costs are high

Google does not disclose operating income granularly for its individual advertizing units. Instead, nan institution reports results for nan ‘Google Services’ segment, which includes ‘Google Search & other’, ‘YouTube ads’, ‘Google Network’ and ‘Google Other’. In 2022, nan operating separator for ‘Google Services’ was 34%. Note that nan different segments, ‘Google Cloud’ and ‘Other Bets’ are some loss-making. Google’s nett separator successful 2022 stood astatine 21.20%.

AI-powered searches are estimated to beryllium 10 times costlier for Google than accepted searches. On nan past earnings call, an expert asked astir nan “impact connected CapEx of nan higher compute strength of these AI tools, perchance impacting margins complete nan adjacent mates of years”. CFO Ruth Porat responded:

It is much compute-intensive, but besides opens up galore much services and products for our users, for creators, for advertisers…

we're very focused connected further optimizing nan costs of compute, and that's crossed each elements, information center, servers and our proviso chain. So we're continuing to put pinch a keen lens connected nan return connected that capital…

we are focused connected durable improvements to our disbursal base… they return longer to implement, execute. They're successful process now, and they proceed to build connected themselves and proceed to supply added upside arsenic we spell done time, which is why I indicated you would spot much of an effect connected 2024 than successful 2023.

Durable improvements should amended costs power overtime, but intensifying title whitethorn subdue Return connected Investment [ROI] potential, and unit apical statement growth. Moreover, Google’s executives often proclaimed nan efficacy of nan AI-powered advertizing and trading solution, Performance Max, connected nan past net call. Performance Max was launched successful November 2021, and is an upgrade from smart shopping campaigns, aimed astatine bolstering unit activity done Google.

Despite nan AI-driven advancement, Google Advertising gross grew by conscionable 7.15% successful 2022, pinch executives chiefly blaming macro conditions for nan slowing growth. Comparatively, Amazon’s advertizing business grew 21.11% complete nan aforesaid period. The constituent is, durable improvements successful Google’s costs building whitethorn not needfully consequence successful separator description , arsenic nan intensifying title successful AI-driven services whitethorn subdue gross maturation potential.

Google’s nett separator of 21.20% remains considerably higher than nan assemblage median of 3.38%. Nevertheless, barring nan ‘stay astatine home’ boost during nan pandemic, Google’s nett separator has been trending mostly little for complete a decade.

Google Net Margin


Google’s highly profitable advertizing business has been subsidizing its loss-making segments, peculiarly Google Cloud, for complete a decade. If Google’s advertizing section itself faces separator compression going guardant amid nan intensifying AI race, Google’s nett separator could beryllium successful trouble.

Google banal presently trades astatine a Forward P/E of 18.34x, while nan assemblage median stands astatine 18.70x. The marketplace is correct not to delegate a premium valuation to Google stock, fixed nan dire outlook for profitability.

Habitual hunt behaviour

On a affirmative note, bulls for illustration to proclaim that Google is well-ingrained into people’s hunt activity habits, and changing this wont towards replacement services would beryllium an uphill battle. In February 2023, 93.37% of worldwide search queries were done Google. The tech elephantine surely has a beardown reign complete nan hunt motor market, bolstered by beardown marque recognition. In fact, amid nan hype astir ChatGPT, AI advisor Tobias Zwingmann pointed retired successful December 2022 that "the measurement it useful presently is group usage ChatGPT and past spell to Google to verify nan results", which is testament to Google’s marque power.

That being said, while altering hunt behaviour would beryllium challenging, it is not impossible. Google whitethorn beryllium well-ingrained into nan habits of definite generations, but younger generations whitethorn not needfully beryllium arsenic attached to Google, particularly amid nan emergence of caller platforms for illustration TikTok, wherever users often spell to study much astir definite taxable matters (e.g. get financial advice).

Additionally, regulatory scrutiny looking to dismantle nan Apple-Google partnership, whereby ‘Google’ is group arsenic nan default hunt motor connected Apple devices, could further undermine nan hunt giant’s expertise to prolong nan habitual hunt behaviour of users.

Is Google a buy?

The hasty rollout of Google Bard whitethorn upend Google’s halfway advertizing business. The entreaty of advertisement bidding to rank higher successful hunt results is undermined, arsenic nan likelihood of users scrolling little to find website links is subdued if Bard’s consequence is sufficient. This presents a notable threat to Google’s search-related advertizing revenue.

Ad gross done ‘Google Network’ would besides suffer arsenic conversational-style queries done Bard trim nan request for users to sojourn websites to find answers, reducing advertisement belief connected web pages. While Google is encouraging users to click connected websites to study much astir something, users whitethorn beryllium inclined to proceed to chatting pinch Bard to find nan answers.

Google walks a good statement betwixt optimizing nan trustworthiness/ usefulness of Bard responses and optimizing advertisement revenue. On nan different hand, nan fee-based business exemplary of OpenAI could augment users’ cognition of ChatGPT Plus arsenic offering unbiased and useful answers, though it would request to beryllium its superior reliability complete Google to triumph marketplace share.

The finance organization is correct not to delegate a premium valuation to Google stock, amid nan dire outlook for profitability. Given nan AI-related risks and uncertainties ahead, nan banal is not worthy buying. Nexus Research has a ‘hold’ standing connected nan stock.

This article was written by

Nexus Research floor plan picture

Striving to uncover semipermanent finance opportunities (10+ years) done in-depth investigation and analysis. Nexus Research seeks to measure and comparison business strategies to find a company’s imaginable for marketplace penetration, gross maturation and profit separator description . During marketplace downturns, stocks often go inexpensive very fast, creating various finance opportunities astatine once. Amid specified circumstances, investors often deficiency nan clip to investigation a institution thoroughly earlier making finance decisions, retired of fearfulness that they will miss retired connected charismatic introduction points. Therefore, Nexus Research not only uncovers present-day buying opportunities, but besides offers extended insights connected coagulated companies pinch promising maturation imaginable contempt costly valuations, thereby allowing investors to beryllium fresh and make well-informed finance decisions erstwhile nan banal becomes much reasonably valued.

Disclosure: I/we person nary stock, action aliases akin derivative position successful immoderate of nan companies mentioned, and nary plans to initiate immoderate specified positions wrong nan adjacent 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my ain opinions. I americium not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I person nary business narration pinch immoderate institution whose banal is mentioned successful this article.

Editor: Naga

Read other contents from at
More Source