Estimating The True Size Of China's Gold Reserves

William_Potter/iStock via Getty Images

According to my analysis, nan Chinese cardinal slope owned 4,309 tonnes of golden connected December 31, 2022, which is much than double than what is officially disclosed. My estimate would make China nan 2nd largest golden reserve state after nan US. The Chinese backstage assemblage holds 23,745 tonnes, bringing nan full magnitude of golden successful China to 28,054 tonnes.

China and European countries are successful statement to equalize their ratios of monetary golden comparative to GDP successful bid to hole for a world golden standard.

Introduction

For estimating nan existent size of nan golden reserves of nan Chinese cardinal slope (the People’s Bank of China, PBoC), we first request to make a clear favoritism betwixt monetary golden (owned by a cardinal bank) and non-monetary golden (owned by nan backstage sector). Without getting into nan exact mechanics of nan Chinese golden market here, suffice to opportunity that only non-monetary golden imports into China are publically disclosed. These imports are required to beryllium sold first done nan Shanghai Gold Exchange (SGE), and for taxation and liquidity reasons virtually each different proviso (mine and recycled gold) successful China is sold done nan SGE arsenic well. On nan request side, backstage marketplace participants get golden astatine nan SGE. It’s improbable nan PBoC buys astatine nan SGE.

Any study astir nan PBoC’s golden reserves based connected known import numbers and home excavation proviso is flawed, therefore. It’s existent that successful nan past nan PBoC was nan superior golden trader successful China—being nan monopoly wholesale purchaser and seller—but this has changed since nan Chinese golden marketplace was liberalized pinch nan launch of nan SGE successful 2002.

These are nan reasons why nan PBoC doesn’t bargain golden connected nan SGE:

1. The PBoC wants to diversify its overseas speech reserves—worth much than $3 trillion astatine nan clip of writing—by buying golden chiefly pinch US dollars. Gold connected nan SGE is exclusively quoted successful renminbi: not suitable for nan PBoC.

2. As we shall spot nan PBoC prefers to bargain golden covertly. If it buys golden overseas pinch US dollars, nan monetary golden is exempt from being reported successful world customs data erstwhile crossing borders (non-monetary golden is not exempt). Buying overseas allows nan PBoC to acquisition and repatriate golden without leaving a trace successful nan nationalist realm.

3. Gold connected nan SGE often trades astatine a premium. The PBoC is much apt to bargain golden that is priced little abroad.

4. In 2015 I was successful interaction pinch a precious metals trader astatine a ample Chinese state-owned bank. He told maine that nan PBoC buys golden done Chinese proxy banks, specified arsenic nan 1 he worked for, successful nan world OTC marketplace from bullion banks and refineries in, for example, South Africa and Switzerland. Not astatine nan SGE.

Another personification I had nan opportunity to converse wrong 2015, let’s telephone him Mister-X, worked astatine 1 of nan large consultancy firms. He was good connected successful nan industry. Somewhat akin to my Chinese source, he told to maine nan PBoC uses proxies to acquisition golden successful nan London OTC golden market.

Early 2017, writer and golden commentator Jim Rickards met pinch 3 heads of nan precious metals departments of ample Chinese banks. Rickards stated successful nan Gold Chronicles podcast published January 17, 2017 (25:00):

What I don’t cognize is astir nan Shanghai Gold Exchange sales, they’re beautiful transparent, really overmuch of that is backstage and really overmuch of that is nan authorities [PBoC]. And I was benignant of guessing 50/50, 70/30, whatever. What they told me, and these guys are nan dealers, it’s 100% private. Meaning, nan authorities operates done wholly abstracted channels. The authorities does not run done nan Shanghai Gold Exchange. … None of what’s going connected nan Shanghai Gold Exchange is going to nan People’s Bank of China.

Lastly, in 2014 nan President of nan SGE Transaction Department said successful interview:

The PBoC does not bargain golden done nan SGE.

Until I bump into grounds convincing maine of nan opposite, my conclusion is nan PBoC doesn’t bargain golden connected nan SGE and frankincense each known supplies successful China (import, excavation output, recycled gold) must beryllium eliminated from our study for estimating nan PBoC’s existent holdings. Most likely, nan PBoC buys golden overseas and from location ships it to vaults successful Beijing.

Estimating PBoC Gold Reserves

Let america first person a look astatine what nan PBoC has disclosed successful nan past.

Given China is nan 2nd largest system successful nan world, it has monolithic overseas speech reserves but small golden reserves comparative to full reserves, it’s nan proverbial elephant successful nan golden market.

We often spot agelong periods of nary purchases and past a abrupt ample summation successful reserves, which suggests they mostly bargain by stealth. In June 2015 nan Chinese cardinal slope disclosed to person 1,658 tonnes, up from 1,054 tonnes a period prior. Obviously, 604 tonnes weren’t bought successful 1 month.

On 1 hand, nan PBoC wants to show nan world they are buying golden to drawback up pinch nan West, support renminbi internationalization, and move distant from nan dollar. On nan different hand, they don’t want to disclose excessively much, aliases they would stone nan golden marketplace and thrust nan value up, which is not successful their interest, yet. The Chinese cardinal bank’s liking is to accumulate golden for itself, but it besides has a argumentation of “storing golden among nan people” to fortify China’s economical information (source, page 27). If nan value rises, China arsenic a full tin bargain little gold.

In March 2013, lawman Chinese cardinal slope politician Yi Gang told nan press:

If nan Chinese authorities were to bargain excessively overmuch gold, golden prices would surge, a script that will wounded Chinese consumers.

We will ever support golden successful mind arsenic an action successful reserve assets and investments.

We are capable to import 500-600 tons a year, aliases more, but we will besides return into information a unchangeable golden market.

Some analysts person interpreted nan “500–600 tonnes a year” arsenic what nan PBoC buys each azygous year. It’s much likely, though, Yi referred to nan weight imported successful 2012 by nan Chinese backstage assemblage and nan PBoC successful aggregate. Global cross-border statistic show countries nett exported 590 tonnes successful non-monetary golden to China successful 2012. Add immoderate nan PBoC bought, and you get “500–600 tonnes a year, aliases more.”

Another statement why nan PBoC doesn’t bargain 500 tonnes each twelvemonth is because nan golden marketplace is successful changeless flux. If nan value goes up nan PBoC can’t bargain overmuch for reasons conscionable mentioned. If nan value goes down nan PBoC tin acquisition hundreds of tonnes connected sale.

In a previous article, I person explained that for astatine slightest 90 years nan golden value is group successful nan West. The East dampens volatility by ramping up purchases erstwhile nan value declines, and lowering purchases erstwhile nan value rises. Many countries successful Asia, for illustration Thailand, moreover move into nett sellers erstwhile nan value goes up. This study rhymes pinch Yi’s remarks from 2013: nan Chinese don’t group nan golden price. (In precocious 2022 and January 2023, Chinese buying was beardown while nan value went up, but it’s excessively soon to corroborate a inclination reversal.)

After having researched nan existent size of nan PBoC’s golden hoard for immoderate years now, I reason location is but 1 attack to get adjacent to what they really have: done intelligence from those dealing pinch nan PBoC: bullion bankers and group astatine refineries and unafraid logistics companies astir nan world. The pursuing study is solely based connected manufacture sources.

Every 4th nan World Gold Council (WGC) publishes nan Gold Demand Trends (GDT) report, which contains statistic provided by Metals Focus (MF) connected mining output, scrap supply, recently fabricated jewelry sold, unit barroom demand, ETF hoarding aliases dishoarding, etc. In these reports location is simply a azygous sum divulged for nan charismatic sector: a nett acquisition aliases waste by each cardinal banks and world financial institutions, specified arsenic nan Bank for International Settlements (BIS), International Monetary Fund (IMF), and European Central Bank (ECB), combined. This is an estimate based connected MF’s section investigation and doesn’t needfully align pinch what cardinal banks openly declare. From nan WGC:

Central banks

Net purchases (i.e. gross purchases little gross sales) by cardinal banks and different charismatic assemblage institutions, including supra nationalist entities specified arsenic nan IMF. Swaps … are excluded.

A … captious root is confidential accusation [by MF] regarding unrecorded income and purchases.

For example, erstwhile MF—a consultancy patient successful adjacent interaction pinch bullion bankers and group astatine refineries and unafraid logistics companies astir nan world—judges nan PBoC bought 50 tonnes successful Q1 2023, this tonnage will beryllium attributed to charismatic assemblage activity successful its respective GDT report.

By comparing MF’s charismatic assemblage estimates to what nan charismatic assemblage publishes, we tin deduct what’s bought surreptitiously. People acquainted pinch nan matter, but for illustration to enactment anonymous, told maine that nan mostly of these clandestine acquisitions tin beryllium ascribed to nan Chinese cardinal bank. Saudi Arabia is besides known for buying successful secret. Let’s opportunity 80% of nan quality betwixt MF’s information and nan charismatic numbers released by nan IMF are PBoC acquisitions.

Since 2010, erstwhile MF’s estimates started, nan gross quality has mushroomed to 1,945 tonnes, arsenic tin beryllium seen successful nan floor plan below.

For nan information “reported by nan IMF,” I added nan holdings of each cardinal banks, nan ECB, IMF, and nan BIS’ full holdings, arsenic noted successful nan WGC’s “Quarterly times bid connected World Official Gold Reserves since 2000.” Of this total, I subtracted nan golden swaps (taken from nan yearly and monthly reports) of nan BIS, because MF doesn’t see these erstwhile estimating charismatic assemblage buying. The resulting bid differs from nan IMF’s “World” series.

The PBoC frankincense holds astatine slightest 1,556 tonnes (80% of 1,945 tonnes) much than what they disclosed past December (2,010 tonnes), which totals 3,566 tonnes. But really do we cognize what happened earlier 2010 erstwhile MF’s information begins?

Mister-X told maine successful 2015 that it was very difficult for his institution to spell connected grounds pinch what they genuinely deliberation nan Chinese cardinal slope owns. The PBoC is very influential and upsetting them would make his company’s operations successful nan mainland impossible. Though he told maine that erstwhile nan PBoC announced to person 1,658 tonnes successful June 2015, his patient estimated that successful reality, they held doubly arsenic overmuch (3,317 tonnes). I’m tempted to judge Mister-X because this tonnage would make much consciousness than nan charismatic number comparative to, i.e., China’s immense overseas speech reserves. If we presume nan PBoC held 3,317 tonnes successful June 2015, and we adhd 80% of nan furtive investments trailed by MF since then, we get astatine 4,309 tonnes connected December 31, 2022.

How overmuch golden did nan PBoC bargain covertly earlier 2010? According to my math, they did 1,700 tonnes successful unreported procurements from nan 1990s, erstwhile nan PBoC held 395 tonnes, until 2010*.

The further backmost successful clip nan much absorbing it gets. After China’s hardline communist leader Mao Zedong died successful 1976, a much market-oriented system was system nether nan guidance of Deng Xiaoping. Individual golden prospecting was allowed successful 1978 (source, page 97), though each output was required to beryllium sold to nan PBoC.

In 1983, nan Bank of China—the PBoC’s commercialized limb that handled overseas operations (source, page 98)—exported 120 tonnes of nan PBoC’s gold, originated from home mining, to London to speech for dollars.

China’s caller economical exemplary soon bore fruit. Instead of having to waste home excavation output to raise overseas exchange, nan PBoC was buying golden successful London from nan Dutch Central Bank (DNB) successful 1992. An article successful Dutch Newspaper NRC Handelsblad from March 27, 1993, astir a 400 tonnes golden waste from DNB is profoundly informative:

For traders successful nan world golden market, location is nary uncertainty that nan People’s Bank of China (PBoC) has bought a portion of nan 400 tonnes of gold,… which DNB has sold precocious past twelvemonth [1992] successful utmost secrecy.

“With 99 percent certainty we cognize that nan People’s Bank of China has been 1 of nan buyers of nan Dutch gold”, said Philip Klapwijk from Goldfields Mining Services… Also, different London bullion dealers person a beardown suspicion that China was progressive successful nan golden income of DNB. “We person noted that nan Chinese cardinal slope has bought golden successful caller months”, said John Coley of nan London bullion trader Sharp Pixley and spokesperson of nan London Bullion Market Association.

On 29 September Duisenberg [DNB President] sent a missive to Kok [Dutch Minister of Finance] successful which he explained that nan waste was intended “to equalize our golden holdings comparative to different important golden holding nations.”

Kok agreed connected 2 October and successful nan autumn respective income transaction followed successful nan London guardant market. The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) acted arsenic an intermediary.

Duisenberg expanded connected nan golden income astatine a BIS gathering connected January 12, 1993. The waste had already taken place, only nan golden had yet to beryllium delivered. Not each members of nan BIS welcomed nan Dutch move, nor were they consulted for its decision.

It’s intolerable DNB entered nan golden marketplace itself because this would instantly leak successful nan closed world of golden trading. The fewer remaining Dutch players successful nan golden marketplace are tiny. In London, location are 4 awesome golden traders: Sharps Pixley, Samuel Montague, Mase Westpac and Rothschild. According to John Coley, spokesperson of nan London Bullion Market Association, it was evident that DNB would usage nan BIS arsenic an intermediary. Duisenberg is very good known successful Basel because he was President of The Board of nan BIS from 1988 to 1990.

“Part of nan waste was handled disconnected nan market”, says Philip Klapwijk… He says he came to this conclusion because nan value of golden past year, though somewhat down, should person shown overmuch greater fluctuations if 400 tonnes had been sold successful nan market…

The BIS astir apt contacted nan People’s Bank of China arsenic nan buyer. Why nan People’s Republic of China? “The Chinese emotion gold,” says an expert, and he refers to nan immense Taiwanese golden purchases successful 1987. Second, China has ample dollar surpluses arsenic a consequence of spectacular economical growth. And third, China announced that it is moving to build up its reserves successful bid to bring it much successful statement pinch nan size of Chinese GDP.

Presumably, nan summation successful China’s golden reserves will ne'er beryllium visible. The statistic produced by nan IMF for China grounds nan aforesaid magnitude of golden for a decade [395 tonnes] …. China experts, however, cognize that nan People’s Bank has further concealed golden reserves, which are held extracurricular nan statistic … If portion of nan golden reserves of DNB person been added to these, arsenic galore suspect, nary 1 will ever officially know.

NRC Handelsblad is simply a respected newspaper successful nan Netherlands. Knowledge by manufacture insiders pinch respect to covert PBoC acquisitions arsenic early arsenic 1992, whitethorn explicate really nan Chinese cardinal slope had accumulated a full of 3,317 tonnes by 2015. To springiness you an idea, DNB sold 400 tonnes successful 1992 and an further 700 tonnes successful nan pursuing years. Other European cardinal banks sold different 3,000 tonnes complete this play (“to equalize … golden holdings comparative to different important golden holding nations”). Not each could person been bought by nan PBoC, but still. In nan 1990s nan golden value was declining truthful location were much sellers than buyers: a business nan PBoC has apt exploited.

The PBoC had nan opportunity to bargain important amounts of gold, successful and disconnected nan market, for decades. It’s not evident each this golden was added to concealed monetary reserves, though. Liberalization of nan Chinese golden market, initiated successful 2002, wasn’t completed until 2007. Chairman of nan SGE Shen Xiangrong stated successful 2003:

Although 4 ample home banks were granted support to import and export golden backmost successful 2002, they person not yet started these cross-border activities, and nan PBOC still remains nan only span connecting nan world bullion marketplace pinch China.

Any shortfall successful home excavation and scrap proviso to meet backstage request successful nan mainland, from 1982 erstwhile jewelry income were first allowed by nan Communist Party, up until astatine slightest until 2003, was supplemented by golden imports by nan PBoC. Even if we knew precisely really overmuch nan PBoC imported since 1992, we would only cognize nan magnitude it accumulated for itself aft offsetting those purchases against proviso shortfalls successful nan home market.

Estimating China’s Private Gold Reserves

How nan Chinese populace has accumulated 23,745 tonnes.

China became a nett importer of golden location successful nan 1990s, according to nan China Gold Market Report 2010 that was co-authored by nan PBoC. This intends Chinese home excavation accumulation hasn’t crossed a separator afterwards.

China Gold Market Report 2010. “Mineral gold” is excavation output and “Others” refers to import. The cardinal slope didn’t bargain aliases waste golden from/to nan home marketplace successful 2010. China astir apt became a nett importer successful 1992 (see erstwhile chapter).

Precious Metals Insights (PMI) estimates that 2,500 tonnes of gold wherever held by nan organization successful nan mainland successful 1994, which is nan “jewelry base” we will commencement disconnected with.

By 2004 nan general prohibition connected bullion possession for Chinese group was lifted and backstage finance took off. In 2007, nan Chinese golden marketplace functioned arsenic was intended by nan PBoC, arsenic full proviso and request went done nan SGE that twelvemonth for nan first time. The China Gold Association (CGA) Yearbook 2007 states (page 39):

2007年，上海黄金交易所黄金入库量394.855 吨，即我国当年的黄金实际供给量

In 2007, nan golden retention measurement astatine nan Shanghai Gold Exchange was 394.855 tonnes, that is, nan existent proviso of golden that twelvemonth …

2007年，上海黄金交易所黄金出库量363.194 吨，即我国当年的黄金需求量，

The magnitude of golden withdrawn from nan warehouses of nan Shanghai Gold Exchange successful 2007, nan full golden request of that year, was 363.194 tonnes …

因而2007年出现了31.661吨未能交割的库存，

Therefore, location was 31.661 tons of undelivered [SGE] inventory successful 2007…

Before 2007 not each proviso and request moved done nan SGE, according to CGA Gold Yearbooks, indicating nan PBoC was still progressive successful nan allocation of metal. We shall presume that starting successful 2007 nan PBoC was nary longer interfering successful nan market.

To cipher backstage reserves, I person added yearly excavation accumulation and non-monetary import since 1994 to nan jewelry base. From this total, I person subtracted openly declared additions by nan PBoC from earlier 2007, because these were presumably sourced, successful part, from home mines. My methodology is not perfect, but it will do.

The floor plan beneath is nan consequence of my calculations connected China’s charismatic and backstage reserves from 1994 done 2022. All shades of bluish are backstage reserves; reddish is cardinal slope reserves.

Estimated Private and Official Chinese Gold Reserves

Conclusion

All successful all, 4,309 tonnes for China’s charismatic golden reserves is nan champion estimate I tin travel up with. Not unrealistic, because from nan infinitesimal China’s system started expanding successful nan 1990s, and it ran a persistent existent relationship surplus, it had capable overseas speech reserves to bargain golden with, and location was a thrust to drawback up pinch different ample economies.

There is nary uncertainty successful my mind that PBoC bought golden from DNB successful 1992. In summation to nan grounds successful NRC Handelsblad, it’s cited successful DNB’s Annual Report 1992 that “demand successful nan Far-East was strong” erstwhile they sold 400 tonnes.

Previously, I person demonstrated connected these pages that European cardinal banks person been preparing for a world golden modular since nan 1970s done equalizing their monetary golden to GDP ratios. Balanced golden to GDP ratios will soft nan modulation to a golden modular (or golden value targeting system) if nan existent world monetary strategy is stretched beyond its limits. The Chinese were successful connected this scheme since nan 1990s.

China communicated successful 1993 (source, NRC Handelsblad) to “build up its [gold] reserves successful bid to bring it much successful statement pinch nan size of Chinese GDP.” The value of this connection is that it can’t beryllium viewed successful isolation. Gold is an internationally traded commodity, and its value is nan aforesaid successful everywhere. The Chinese didn’t say, “we purpose to person golden reserves worthy [i.e.] 10% of our GDP,” because they tin bargain golden and turn their economy, astatine nan extremity of nan time nan golden value is what determines their golden to GDP ratio. What China implicitly said was that it’s aiming to bring its golden to GDP ratio much successful statement pinch different countries.

DNB’s Annual Report 1992 states (emphasis mine): “Within nan EC [European Community], nan Netherlands was and is, when golden reserves are compared to GDP, 1 of nan largest golden holding countries. On this basis, nan Bank [DNB] lowered its golden banal from 1707 tonnes to 1307 tonnes successful nan autumn of 1992.” We cognize DNB yet lowered its reserves to 612 tonnes, bringing it adjacent to nan European mean (currently 4% of GDP).

In nan early 1990s, some nan Netherlands and China were candid astir equalizing their golden reserves comparative to GDP internationally. However, erstwhile I asked DNB successful 2020 astir nan logic for past golden sales, they evaded nan subject. My question:

Is it existent that DNB wanted to execute a much balanced distribution of charismatic golden reserves worldwide pinch nan income of its golden since 1992?

Answer:

De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB) weighs respective factors successful forming an sentiment connected nan full magnitude of golden successful its possession .... We judge that … nan existent magnitude [is] balanced astatine this time. Furthermore, we person nary penetration into nan information of different cardinal banks to beryllium capable to make statements astir their golden reserves and golden policy.

A nonsensical reply because we cognize gold income were coordinated successful Europe and nan overarching argumentation was balancing reserves.

Why did this go a secret? Duisenberg must person agitated nan US erstwhile he expanded connected DNB’s income to China astatine nan BIS gathering connected January 12, 1993. In NRC Handelsblad we read: “Not each members of nan BIS welcomed nan Dutch move…” Major economies balancing golden reserves, fresh to beryllium deployed during a dollar situation to transit to caller monetary system, is not successful America's champion liking to opportunity nan least. It’s feasible nan countries that agreed connected balancing golden reserves silenced themselves to debar conflict pinch Uncle Sam.

Because we cognize astir an world effort of equalizing reserves, DNB trading golden to China successful 1992 made consciousness arsenic nan Netherlands had excessively overmuch golden (1,707 tonnes) and China excessively small (395 tonnes), some of their Gross Domestic Product being astir nan same.

World Bank

On nan non-monetary side, China wants backstage golden reserves to beryllium proportionate to its peers too. Sun Zhaoxue, President of nan China Gold Association, wrote successful 2012 successful Qiushi mag (the main world diary of nan Chinese Communist Party’s Central Committee):

as an important portion of China’s golden reserve system, we should besides promote individuals to put successful gold. Practice has proven that backstage golden reserves are an effective supplement to charismatic reserves and are very important for maintaining nationalist financial security. World Gold Council statistic show that Chinese individuals person little than 5 grams of golden per capita, a important quality to nan world mean of much than 20 grams.

Multiplying 5 grams by 1.3 cardinal group (the Chinese organization successful 2012) equals astir 7,000 tonnes, which matches my estimate of Chinese backstage reserves held astatine nan extremity of 2011. My estimate for Chinese backstage reserves successful 2022 is astir 24,000 tonnes, divided by 1.4 cardinal group (the Chinese organization successful 2022), equals 17 grams per capita. China’s non-monetary golden reserves are adjacent to nan world average.

China’s monetary golden to GDP ratio (computed pinch 4,309 tonnes) is 1.5%, which is still little than 2% successful nan US and 4% successful nan eurozone. It’s clear that now is nan clip for nan PBoC to velocity up buying. One, China is still down successful its comparative golden holdings vis-à-vis Western powers. Two, Russia’s dollar assets were stiff owed to nan warfare successful Ukraine and nan Chinese don’t want to suffer to aforesaid fate. Three, nan Chinese organization has accumulated capable already. Remember Yi Gang was considering backstage hoarding erstwhile he deliberated connected really overmuch nan PBoC was capable to bargain successful 2013? That doesn’t person to beryllium an rumor anymore. Tellingly, nan PBoC bought a staggering 522 tonnes successful 2022 (based connected MF data), which was supportive of nan gold price. I deliberation early PBoC procurements, mostly from Russia I suspect, will beryllium supportive of nan golden value arsenic well.

*According to MF’s information nan PBoC bought 1,556 tonnes from January 2010 until December 2022. Meaning, successful 2010 nan PBoC held 1,556 tonnes little than 4,309 (my estimate for 2022), which is 2,754 tonnes. Officially, nan PBoC owned 395 tonnes successful 1982. From past until 2010 nan PBoC bought 659 tonnes, according to nationalist records. The quality betwixt my estimates and nan charismatic information connected purchases complete this play is 1,700 tonnes.

Original Post

Editor's Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.

Jan Nieuwenhuijs is simply a financial interrogator and golden expert astatine Gainesville Coins. Nieuwenhuijs mostly writes astir gold, covering topics specified arsenic nan world beingness golden market, derivative markets, cardinal banks' golden policy, and nan world monetary system.