Better High Yield ETF Buy: JEPI Vs. PEY

JamesBrey

Income ETFs are successful precocious request correct now acknowledgment to rising liking rates. This is because for galore investors - particularly retirees - to warrant holding equities astatine a clip erstwhile CDs are yielding arsenic overmuch arsenic 5%, they request to connection comparable dividend yields alongside maturation potential.

Both nan Invesco High Yield Equity Dividend Achievers ETF (NASDAQ:PEY) and nan JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (NYSEARCA:JEPI) activity to entreaty to income investors by offering precocious yields. As a result, it is not astonishing to spot that they person knowledgeable important assets nether guidance maturation complete nan past year:

Data by YCharts

In this article, we comparison these opportunities broadside by broadside and stock our position connected which is nan amended bargain astatine nan moment.

JEPI Analysis

JEPI is an charismatic finance action for investors owed to its monthly dividend output of 11.9% complete nan trailing 12 months. This dividend payout of astir 1% of nan finance each period is highly appealing, particularly considering JEPI's well-diversified portfolio that is professionally managed and easy to put and sell.

JEPI has a full of 132 holdings, making it highly diversified. Its apical 10 holdings correspond only 14.52% of its full holdings, which is importantly little than PEY's apical 10 holdings. Additionally, only 1.07% of JEPI's portfolio is successful rate and rate equivalents.

JEPI Top Holdings (Seeking Alpha)

The portfolio is chiefly composed of a diversified operation of industrial, financial, wellness care, and user protect stocks.

JEPI Allocation (Seeking Alpha)

Moreover, JEPI sells retired of nan money telephone options connected nan S&P 500 (SPY) to make a higher dividend output for its shareholders. While this strategy whitethorn forfeit immoderate of nan ETF's upside imaginable for accrued rate travel procreation each month, it results successful much unchangeable and predictable short-term full returns by smoothing retired nan broader banal market's spikes and plunges. However, this strategy apt has small effect connected nan fund's semipermanent risk-adjusted full return potential.

PEY Analysis

PEY generates its charismatic 4.21% trailing twelve-month dividend output by kindness of its attraction connected owning precocious yielding ample headdress companies that boast 10 positive twelvemonth dividend maturation streaks. As such, it seeks to way nan Nasdaq U.S. Dividend Achievers 50 Index which is simply nan 50 highest yielding $1 cardinal positive marketplace headdress stocks that person grown their dividends for astatine slightest a decade.

It presently has 52 holdings, making it sufficiently though not exceptionally good diversified. Its apical 10 holdings correspond 29.84% of its full holdings, which makes them reasonably precocious condemnation picks. Additionally, 0% of JEPI's portfolio is successful rate and rate equivalents, truthful it is simply a axenic equity fund.

PEY Top 10 Holdings (Seeking Alpha)

The portfolio is chiefly composed of a diversified operation of industries, pinch nan immense mostly being recovered successful either nan utilities, financials, user defensive, aliases wellness attraction sectors. Unsurprisingly, only 1.95% of its positions are recovered successful exertion fixed that sector's attraction connected maturation investing alternatively than dividends.

PEY Allocation (Seeking Alpha)

Something other that is absorbing to statement is that its disbursal ratio is 0.52%, which is materially higher than JEPI's 0.35% disbursal ratio contempt JEPI being overmuch much actively managed pinch its options trades.

Investor Takeaway: Which Is The Better Buy?

While not being taken into relationship complete a agelong play of time, it is worthy noting that PEY has astir doubled nan full return capacity of JEPI complete nan play wherever some person traded publicly:

Data by YCharts

Data by YCharts

This is astonishing fixed that JEPI has a little disbursal ratio and is system to present much unchangeable capacity complete clip owed to its greater diversification and options trading strategy.

The logic for this is simply because during nan marketplace weakness, location has been a formation to value dividend paying stocks successful general. As a result, PEY's greater attraction successful these names - particularly ones that person proven way records of paying retired charismatic and consistently increasing dividends - is sparkling successful much of a risk-off environment. Additionally, arsenic nan floor plan supra shows, nan past twelvemonth has been filled pinch beautiful crisp rises and dips successful nan market, which tends to activity against JEPI's strategy arsenic they often suffer retired connected immoderate of nan upside during beardown marketplace rallies.

That said, moving forward, this attack whitethorn not ever present alpha comparative to nan SPY aliases moreover JEPI. In general, we would expect PEY to outperform JEPI during periods of precocious volatility, while JEPI will apt outperform PEY during periods of flatter marketplace behaviour arsenic their covered calls will often expire worthless successful specified a scenario. As a result, shareholders will beryllium capable to pouch nan options premiums without having to forfeit overmuch (if any) upside. An further tailwind for JEPI complete nan semipermanent is its little disbursal ratio. While it whitethorn not look for illustration a ample quality successful nan short-term, nan laws of compounding bespeak that this mini quality could lead to meaningful outperformance for JEPI comparative to PEY complete nan long-term, each other being equal.

The main advantage of JEPI, isolated from its little disbursal ratio, is its expertise to present accordant rate flows to shareholders complete time. This makes it an charismatic action for retirees who are surviving connected finance income, arsenic they tin trust connected JEPI's rate travel and reinvest nan surplus accordingly.

Additionally, JEPI's attack mitigates immoderate of nan marketplace risk, arsenic retirees tin retreat their income during prolonged carnivore markets from options premiums alternatively of eroding their holdings. While nan upside imaginable is constricted during bull markets, retirees mostly worth downside protection much than upside imaginable arsenic they prioritize covering surviving expenses done marketplace cycles and amid macroeconomic uncertainty.

While PEY whitethorn beryllium preferable for those bullish connected nan banal market's outlook and wanting to harvester income pinch uncapped upside potential, JEPI is simply a amended action for retirees successful an uncertain macro environment.

High Yield Investor takes a akin attack by complementing high-quality full return compounders pinch higher-yielding instruments, resulting successful a portfolio that has outperformed nan marketplace since inception pinch a ~7% dividend yield.

Our 2023 Blowout Sale of nan Year is Here!

For a Limited-Time - You tin subordinate Seeking Alpha’s #1 rated organization of high-yield investors astatine a steep discount! 

Try it Free for 2-Weeks. If you don’t for illustration it, we won’t complaint you a penny! We person complete 150 five-star reviews from happy members who are already profiting from our high-yield strategies.

We walk 1000s of hours and complete $100,000 per twelvemonth researching nan marketplace for nan astir profitable finance opportunities and stock nan results pinch you astatine a mini fraction of nan cost.

                  (Limited to only 50 spots!)